Healthfirst Medicare Advantage OTC Benefit Guide 2026

Healthfirst OTC Benefits for New York Members

Healthfirst, a leading Medicare Advantage plan in New York, provides OTC benefits through the Healthy Benefits Plus program. As a member, you receive a quarterly allowance to purchase health and wellness products at participating locations throughout New York City and surrounding areas.

Your Benefit Amount

• Plan-dependent: Healthfirst OTC benefits range from $40 to $200 per quarter depending on your specific plan. CompleteCare plans generally offer higher OTC amounts
• Quarterly reset: Benefits reset on January 1, April 1, July 1, and October 1. Mark these dates on your calendar so you don't miss out
• No cash value: Your OTC benefit cannot be converted to cash. It can only be used for eligible health and wellness products

How to Use Your Benefit

• Healthy Benefits Plus card: Your OTC benefit is loaded onto your Healthy Benefits Plus card. Use it at checkout at participating stores just like a debit card
• In-store shopping: Visit participating retailers in New York including Walgreens, CVS, Rite Aid, and select independent pharmacies. Eligible products will be automatically recognized at checkout
• Online ordering: Visit the Healthy Benefits Plus website to browse the catalog and order products for home delivery. Especially convenient for members with limited mobility

New York-Specific Tips

• Neighborhood pharmacies: Many independent pharmacies in NYC accept Healthy Benefits Plus. Check the Healthfirst website for a store locator specific to your neighborhood
• Delivery services: Several Healthfirst partner pharmacies offer free delivery within NYC. Ask your local pharmacy if they deliver OTC benefit orders
• Community health centers: Some Healthfirst community health centers have OTC product stations where you can use your benefit during a visit